The European Union’s top court ordered Poland on Friday to immediately stop applying a law that lowered the retirement age for Supreme Court judges, forcing some 20 off the bench.
The interim injunction from the European Court of Justice also obliges EU member Poland to reinstate the judges who had to retire early after the law took effect in July. It lowered the age limit for Supreme Court service from 70 to 65.
The powerful leader of Poland’s conservative ruling party, Jaroslaw Kaczynski, said Poland would observe EU law, but not whether the government would comply with the order. He also said the government would do all it could to “defend our state interest.”
The European Commission, the EU’s executive branch, asked for the injunction while the Court of Justice considers its challenge to the age cap as a violation of EU laws on judicial independence and the right to a fair trial. A ruling in the main proceedings is expected later.
Supreme Court judges, arguing the forced retirements are an infringement of Poland’s Constitution, also have sought the European court’s opinion.
Kaczynski’s Law and Justice party has made overhauling the judicial system a key focus since it came to power in 2015. The government maintains that removing justices who were active during Poland’s communist era will make the courts more efficient and fairer.
Among the evidence Court of Justice Vice President Rosario Silva de Lapuerta cited in the order was “a profound and immediate change in the composition of the Supreme Court” since the disputed law went into force. Along with the retirements, an increase in court seats from 93 to 120 created more than 44 vacancies, and President Andrzej Duda has filled at least 27 of them, Lapuerta said.
“Because of the Supreme Court’s authority to give the final word in legal cases, “there would be a real risk of serious and irreparable damage to individuals if the interim measures were not adopted,” her order stated.
Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki said the government received the order and would “respond after analyzing it.” The Foreign Ministry noted that the Court of Justice had not yet heard Poland’s legal arguments in the case.
The director of Amnesty International’s European institutions office said that the ruling showed it was “unacceptable for Poland to ignore EU’s most fundamental principles.”
“Anything but immediate and full compliance with this binding court order would clearly show, once again, that the Polish authorities have complete disregard for the rule of law,” Covadonga de la Campa said.
The Supreme Court’s first president, Malgorzata Gersdorf, was one of the justices forced off the bench by the retirement age revision. She said she was glad the European court supported Poland’s judges, but regretted the “shame” the divisive issue brought Poland.
Source: The Associated Press